REVIEWS

ViewSonic M1 portable projector

Huawei Mate 20 Pro

Waze navigation app on Apple CarPlay

Apple Watch Series 4

Apple iPhone XS Max

Google Pixel 3 XL

Fitbit Charge 3

Rowenta Intense Air Pure Purifier

iOS 12

Bissell CrossWave PetPro Multi-Surface Cleaner

Casper Dog Bed

Samsung Galaxy Note 9

Samsung Galaxy Tab S4

MacBook Pro 13 (2018)

2018 Hyundai Ioniq Electric Plus PHEV Driver

Dyson Pure Cool HEPA Air Purifier and Fan

BlackBerry Key 2

Sonos Beam

Huawei P20 Pro

Apple HomePod

Google Home Max 

Motorola Moto G6

Fitbit Versa

Sennheiser Ambeo Smart headset

Amazon Echo Spot

Apple iPad (2018)

Spectre x360 13 2-in-1

Samsung Galaxy S9

Acer Windows Mixed Reality Headset and Controller

ScoopFree Original Self Cleaning Litter Box

Kindle Oasis (2017) - The Perfect eBook reader

Azio's Retro Classic Mechanical Keyboard

Google Pixel Buds

Jaybird Run wireless bluetooth headphones

BlackBerry Motion

Apple iPhone X

Microsoft Xbox One X

Miele Blizzard CX1 Hardfloor PowerLine

Google Pixel 2 and Pixel 2 XL

Sonos One Smart Speaker

Windows 10 Fall Creators Update

Anki Overdrive - Fast and Furious Edition

Apple TV 4K

Google Home Mini

Fitbit Flyer

Fitbit Ionic

Huawei P10

Apple Watch Series 3 GPS + Cellular

2018 Toyota C-HR

Apple iPhone 8 Plus

Nomad leather case for iPhone 8 Plus

Alcatel A50

Tile Pro Sport smart tracker

27-inch Apple iMac with Retina 5K Display

Anki Cozmo programmable robot

Microsoft Surface Laptop

Motorola Moto Z2 Play

« Microsoft co-founder Paul Allen passes away at 65 | Main | The iPad is finally getting a proper version of Photoshop in 2019 »
Monday
Oct152018

Review: Google Pixel 3 XL

By Gadjo Cardenas Sevilla

Google's vision of what a perfect smartphone should be is simple. They want each user to have 'their own personal Google,' which makes the Google Pixel 3, the boldest attempt at harnessing the computational power of Google in a mobile device you carry in your pocket Hit jump for our full review.

In terms of hardware, the Pixel line of phones has not been the most inspired or luxurious to come to market. The first Pixel looked and felt like a soviet-designed prototype, the second generation had some flourishes such as two-tone colours and bright sleep/wake buttons, but still fell short in some smartphone aficionado's eyes.

Despite the decent and recognizable design, the Pixel 2 still felt tied to old school smartphone design. No water resistance, no wireless charging and only a single camera? What's up with that.

Third Generation hardware


The Pixel 3 and the Pixel 3 XL correct the course with an all-glass body to enable wireless charging. These new Pixels are water resistant with a respectable IP86 rating. We now have dual front-facing cameras for widescreen selfies even as we retain the single 12-megapixel camera in the rear.

The Pixel design language, ostensibly based on Android's own Material Design framework, is clearly evidenced in the Pixel 3 line. The aesthetic is all about subtlety and nuance, texture and levels, and it translates well on to hardware.

The Pixel 3 XL has great hand feel, the glass back is etched to offer two distinct textures. A high gloss finish and a grippier matte treatment. Good news is that this feels like the most luxurious Pixel yet. Bad news, the glass will pick up scratches and microabrasions soon as you remove it from the packaging.

It was thoughtful for Google to include a nice fabric case for my Pixel 3 XL, that's where the phone will live until I can get Urban Armour Gear's rugged case. As lavish and smooth as this phone is, it will require a case for protection.

Having a smartphone that's encased in glass has its benefits including a more organic feel, better antenna transmission and wireless charging. Unfortunately, the tradeoff is that Pixel 3 is more delicate than its polycarbonate or metal predecessors.

The same can be said for the iPhone XS and any recent Samsung flagship, which also tout all-glass designs front and back.

Software Leads the Way

Google has flexed its computational muscle as the key advantage of the Pixel 3.

Android P on the Pixel 3 XL simply flies and is a prime example of what a great mobile OS matched with the right hardware can do.

Android P comes alive on the Pixel 3 and offers a seamless, sleek and instantaneous experience. Everything from opening apps, multitasking, taking photos and videos as well as invoking Google Assistant happens quickly with no perceptible lag.

Because of the great software implementation, the Pixel 3 XL is quite manageable even if it is a large smartphone with a 6.3-inch display, 

The Notch

The Pixel 3 XL has a sizeable notch that breaks up the symmetry of an otherwise edge-to-edge design. This notch is deeper than what you’d see on the iPhone X line of phones or any of the various copycats in the market. 

There’re two good reasons for the notch on the Pixel 3, it is the placement of dual front facing cameras that can offer wide-angle selfie shots. Now, many pundits seem to be getting bent out of shape because of the notch but like with most smartphones bearing this feature, it is something one gets used to.

Google will offer the option to hide the notch on the Pixel 3XL using software, but by doing so, you miss out on the other information that can be displayed in that area.

I can see how some may be dismayed at the presence of a notch. But trust me, just like with the iPhone X a year ago, you soon get used to it.

Display Dominance

The notch removes focus on the new OLED display which is stunning and a superb update over the Pixel 2 XL's muddy and dim display.

The Pixel 3 XL's 6.3-inch QHD+ OLED display with a 523ppi pixel density is superb and rivals the best that Samsung and Apple have to offer on their large format phones. 

Not only is this large display immersive and great to look at, it is super responsive to touch with no perceptible lag even when navigating HD videos.

Displays by themselves are half of the experience when consuming content. Google has also looked after the sound aspect of the Pixel 3 XL. The front-facing stereo speakers are surprisingly loud, clear and well defined. Google says they are as loud as the speaker on a Google Home mini and I must agree.

I really enjoyed watching videos and listening to music on the Pixel 3 XL and found the combination of a large and lavish display plus the full sound of the front-firing stereo speakers to be exceptionally executed.

These speakers are tuned by a Grammy-award winning producer and you just need to listen to them in person to experience how awesome they sound.

Camera Magic

The crowning glory of the Pixel line since its inception has been its camera performance. While the competition is adding multiple cameras to their devices to approximate performance from DSLR's, Google is relying on computational photography.

The Pixel 3 line has a lot to live up to, the Pixel 2 is still a heavy favourite for best smartphone camera. This will likely continue with the Pixel 3 XL which adds a prodigious number of features to what is already an outstanding set of shooters.

The dual front facing cameras, designed for taking wide-angle selfies, are outstanding and give wide-screen selfie or goupfie shots without requiring a selfie stick. 

The wide angle front-facing camera of the Pixel 3 XL makes it possible to get stunning group selfie without a selfie stick

The 12-megapixel rear camera is still a lone wolf, but it brings some astounding capabilities including improved low-light photos, computational zoom functionality, motion tracking for video. Top Shot is a new feature with the ability to take a range of photos as well as suggest the best image from the bunch. 

Here's a shot of a spider from the Pixel 3, zoomed in before taking the shot yet there's still a lot of detail

Taking photos with the Pixel 3 XL is delightful. Having shot images in various conditions including on a bright day, dark evening and indoors, I've been able to produce photos I would not have been able to capture on other smartphone cameras.

The big advantage of the Pixel 3 XL is the implementation of AI or machine learning into the photo capture. Multiple images are taken in succession and processed in-device for the best possible outcome. 

The Pixel 3 XL excel's at low light photography

The most important feature for me is that the photo quality is consistent and natural. Whatever computations juju Google uses to shoot the best photos does not overly process or filter the images. The result is stunning and print-ready photos worth sharing and showing off. 

Video recording on the Pixel 3 XL is also super impressive as the camera has advanced optical image stabilization that does an outstanding job of curbing handheld video shake.

AI Dynamo

Google includes the USB-C headphones in the box with the Pixel 3 Xl. More thank providing decent audio for calls or music playback, these USB Type-C headphones can read back notifications and can even be used for Google Translate translation on the phone.

Just tap the button on the buds and say, "Hey Google, help me translate Japanese." If the language pack is installed, you can get instant translation even without access to the Internet.

Other cool features are quick wireless charging with the Pixel Stand. This also turns the Pixel 3 XL into a Google Home with the ability to show the latest news, recent photos from Google Photos and interface with existing smart home devices.

Google could have just made a powerful and fast Qi charger, but they went the extra mile by creating a delighful range of functionality so your phone does more than just sit there and charge.

Once more, Google's push for software and services shines through what could have been a mundane accessory experience.

 

Pros:

  • Impressive and clear OLED display
  • Loud and crisp front facing stereo speakers
  • Quick wireless charging with Pixel Stand
  • Water resistance
  • Accomplished front-facing and rear cameras with class-leading features
  • Premium glass construction

 

Cons:

  • Limited availability and constrained initial supply
  • Black model is susceptible to scratches and micro abrasions
  • Delicate glass construction necessitates a protective case


Conclusion

The Pixel 3 XL and its smaller brother, the Pixel 3 can be considered the first true 'Made by Google' smartphones in that they've not been outsourced to LG or HTC.

What we have now under the Pixel brand is a confluence of smartphone pedigree. You have the influence of Nexus, influences from Motorola as well as HTC which Google has pulled collectively under its devices.

The result is a cohesive, purposeful and effective culmination of Google's best software services encapsulated in the best hardware it has created.

The Pixel 3 XL as a device is an outstanding achievement in terms of performance, display technology as well as the industry's best computational camera.

This makes the Pixel 3 XL currently the best Android smartphone in the market right now and a definite contender for 2018's phone of the year.

 

Rating: 4.5 out of 5

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>